Friday, November 28, 2008

Yet another time we live to tell the tale

This is not the first time and surely not the last! What we are seeing in Mumbai has virtually sent around a wave of helplessness across the entire country, much more than any previous bomb attacks could have done. In a way, this situation is unprecedented. This is for the first time, at least in recent history, that there have been hostages in any such terror attack. But in many more ways, this attack bears an uncanny resemblance to what has been happening over the last 15 years in India.
Let's face it, terror has become a way of life with us. It just doesn't bother us the way it used to, and more importantly, the way it should!! Every story of a bomb attack is followed by 'Oh-no-not-again' like statements and then soon forgotten about as we get back to the push and pull of our life. There is some blame game played by the authorities for some days but as the story fades away from Page 1 of the newspapers, so it does from our consciousness. And this is where the problem lies!!
Every terror attack whether it happens in local trains or in crowded marketplaces or on the citadel of Indian democracy, is preceded by public callousness and inadvertently followed by indifference.
Before every attack, the public goes about their lives as though we live in a completely immune world with no sense of responsibility towards the society at large. This includes giving our houses on rent to people without verification, not reporting suspicious movements to the police for the fear of legal hassles, not looking around hard enough to notice the subtle hints that the prospective culprits provide and turning a blind eye to the not-so-subtle ones. All as long as we are not affected directly. Reading today's newspapers, I came across a report where a Taj Hotel employee witnessed some suspicious movement near the Gateway of India, where the terrorists responsible for Mumbai attacks came from, just a few minutes before the carnage started. Looking at their huge back packs and general demeanour, he even stopped and asked them who they were. In reply, they said that they were students. The employee was not satisfied with the response but let it go. (Atleast he bothered to ask) The fate of those killed might have been very different if he had not let them go but reported the matter to the local police which is present in the area in large numbers. I am not blaming the gentleman for lack of action, atleast he bothered to ask them who they were while most of us would have just ignored them as long as we were safe. I am just pointing at the larger public consciousness or the lack of thereof. While he lived to tell the tale, many were not as lucky. It is a mere if-but situation, but had the gentleman alerted the police, many many lives could have been saved.

What happens after every attack is even more heart breaking. For a few hours/days after the attack, we find it occupying the place of prominence in all conversation circles. But soon it dies a natural death. With it, also dies the thought for those who have been impacted for life through the attacks, either through physical injury that will leave its scars for a long time or through the loss of dear ones or loss of property etc. Here, is when we also become indifferent to what happens around us. We refuse to learn from our mistakes and will never do till we are affected directly. We never raise fingers at laxity of the authorities when the time is right. We do it only when something has gone miserably wrong. We do it only when the next attack happens (and again for a few days only). At that time, we should infact be asking ourselves if we could have done something to stop the killings, the attacks.
It is always easy to blame the government machinery for not being able to provide security to its citizens. But what we need to understand are a few things:
  • We can't have a billion member strong police and security forces to match the country's population. We can't have a security personnel attached with every citizen. We need to be more aware of our responsibilities as citizens. We need to stop looking around for someone else to pin the blame on and need to start looking at ourselves to shoulder it.
  • Criminals will not stop being criminals. We need to stop being passive. We need to stop being indifferent. We can't pretend that we are back on our two feet when a deadly blow has been dealt to our backbone. Else, sooner than later, this pretence will cost us very dear. Let us not show them that we are not scared therefore we will let them be. Let us instead show them that we are not scared therefore, we will hunt them down and flush them out of our system. We will not let them maim us. Not this time. Not anytime again.
  • We need to understand that terrorism is not a thing of the past. Uptil now, we have been victimised by external forces. In the future, that is not an area which should bother us much since we will be faced with enough difficulty from within our borders. And this will prove to be a far graver challenge because this time we just can't dust our hands of the responsibility that we have by passing the buck to another country. It is the country of those very people who will cause terror and will kill their brothers and sisters in the country. This is a problem that needs more a pro-active approach rather than a reactive one. We need to know how to suppress the problem before it raises its ugly head. We need to identify the problems that will cause another 26/11. We should learn from our mistakes what we didn't learn at the time of Kashmir. Regionalism needs an active approach. It has torn our country and it will only become worse if it is not nipped now. And at that time, let us not look amazed.

Today, I would like to make another point. We really need to make people realise what is right and what merely is their perception of it. In a time that an attack of such magnitude has injured the city, not just for the present but for many days and many months to come, we have surprisingly not seen Mr. Raj Thackrey, the biggest advocate of the 'Mumbaikars cause'. While he sits in the safe confines of his house, hundreds are dying. And in an effort to save to them, we have the national army commandos going out there and risking their lives to save those who are trapped but more importantly, to salvage the reputation of the city. Those commandos who have not thought about even once if they belong to Maharashtra or Bihar or Punjab or Karnataka!! I would really like to ask Mr. Thackrey if we should now leave it to the Mumbaikars alone to handle the mess and also clean it up!!!

When I set out to write this post, I didn't know myself that I had so much to say. But then like I said above, this attack is unprecedented in some ways. For once our politicians are not gunning for each other and are focussing on finding a solution to this menace. But then, we don't know for how long this show of maturity will last.

Just like we don't know if we will live another time to tell the tale....

10 comments:

nitin said...

appreciate ur wise thinkin

Tanu Anand said...

I sooo agree ruchi! man..i had goosebumps when i saw the news..read the news..and now when i read ur blog...!well written..and point taken!

Satish Bhat said...

Hi Ruchi,came across your blog from Aishwarya's.A very heartfelt post.

We are in agreement that the politics of this nation needs to move beyond partisanship. But intriguingly, the educated Indian is perhaps the most politically dormant.Does education numb our civic sense and responsibilities ?

Ruchi Mann said...

@satish:
I couldn't agree more. And I will be very honest here, as a citizen of this country, I never took very seriously the responsibility of casting my vote. These attacks made me sit up and think that I can't be blaming someone else without first doing what I ought to be doing..i went ahead and cast my vote for the very first time in my life!! This is a very small example but just highlights how we are so negligent of the world around us and knowingly so...it is heartbreaking when you think of it. But I guess the educated Indian needs some harsh reminders to make them sit up and take notice. Else,w e are just happy making the big bucks without a cause to worry and that is the bane of this country. and honestly, we aren't too different from the rest.

Ruchi Mann said...

@ Tanu:
I know man!! It was the single most defining image ever..

Malesh Ponnusamy said...

Why is this terror attack causing so much news and concern? In previous attacks kgs of bombs were smuggled in and timed to explode in a fashion, hitting at the heart of the middle class. No show of concern or cries of slogan such as "enough is enough". But when "live" bombs walked in and started to taken on the elite, all hell breaks loose!!! People had condolences for Taj but not for the CST victims. No one questions how RDX comes into our cities, we dont blame intelligence failure when bombay train blasts occurred, but why now? Would any of us be bothered had this attack been on "the slums"? Just because it was Taj and Oberoi, we blow it out of proportion!!!

It is not the political system, religion or external forces but it is the very heart of human nature that is at fault. We are responsible for breeding terrorism.

This sort of attacks have been happening in India - J&K, Assam. But why is that we react so much when it happens to be Mumbai, Taj?

Well, this is just my POV. I do agree with the nature of tragedy but i am just questioning our mindset and reaction.

Btw, do u happen to be a media pro? Good writing.

Ruchi Mann said...

@ finding thyself:
Well I agree that the noise around this attack has been more than ever before. And I don't think most people quantify tragedy by the class it affects. But like I said, this is not the first time or the last that we have been attacked. And the most disappointing measure is human indifference and callousness. We never raise a cery till terror or tragedy or both hit us and hit us hard. This time, probably, the reaction and the coverage we are seeing is because the opinion makers have been at the receiving end. Those who can use media as a tool to voice their grievances have been attacked. Earlier, those who died were the poor and the innocent wo didn't or couldn't come out and voice their desperation or angst. This time it is not so.
Also what differentiates this from the others is that it was a 'blast and over' terror attack. It carried on for 60 hours and it captured the entire nation's imagination like never before. The gravity of the attack was, in a way, unprecedented. India has never had to face a real hostage situation on its own land, with the exception of IC 814. And that too made headlines for a very long time.
So I don't think that we are differentiating on the gravity of the attacks on the basis of class but the kind of the attack.

And yes, i do agree that there was little mention of the CST attack in comparison to those at the Oberoi, Taj and the Nariman House. But again, I would give the authorities the benefit of doubt (actually am not sure) that CST didn't see a hostage situation. That could or could not be the case.

In case it isn't, then we really need to address the internal problem before we target those outside of the country.

And yes, I have been a media student and thanks for your very gracious complmnt.

Malesh Ponnusamy said...

Well, your point taken. The unprecedented international attention this 60 hour ordeal has got needs to be questioned. If it was not for the foreigners trapped in this attack, this news wouldnt have featured as main headlines on Fox, BBC and CNN. And if it wasn't targeted at the Israelis, the US won't be breathing down Pak's neck to take concrete action. When India linked the terror attacks to PAK, the BBC correspondents and experts termed it as a usual "blame game" May be Britain suffered only one casualty and that too that person was a expat who became a citizen. Where as in the case of America, i think it is the Israel pressure which is forcing them to keep a tab on this issue.

Malesh Ponnusamy said...

@Ruchi: Whose India, Whose Icon?
Found this interesting article. Nails what i am trying to say.

Gnani Sankaran- Tamil writer, Chennai.

Watching at least four English news channels, surfing from one another during the last 60 hours of terror strike made me feel a terror of another kind, the terror of assaulting one's mind and sensitivity with cameras,
sound bites and non-stop blabbers. All these channels have been trying to manufacture my consent for a big lie called - Hotel Taj the icon of India.

Whose India, Whose Icon?

It is a matter of great shame that these channels simply did not bother about the other icon that faced the first attack from terrorists - the Chatrapathi Shivaji Terminus (CST) railway station. CST is the true icon of
Mumbai. It is through this railway station hundreds of Indians from Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Rajasthan, West Bengal and Tamilnadu have poured into Mumbai over the years, transforming themselves into Mumbaikars and built the Mumbai of today along with the Marathis and Kolis

But the channels would not recognise this. Nor would they recognise the thirty odd dead bodies strewn all over the platform of CST. No Barkha Dutt
went there to tell us who they were. But she was at Taj to show us the damaged furniture and reception lobby braving the guards. And the TV cameras
did not go to the government run JJ hospital to find out who those 26 unidentified bodies were. Instead they were again invading the battered Taj to try in vain for a scoop shot of the dead bodies of the page 3 celebrities.

In all probability, the unidentified bodies could be those of workers from Bihar and Uttar Pradesh migrating to Mumbai, arriving by train at CST without cell phones and pan cards to identify them. Even after 60 hours
after the CST massacre, no channel has bothered to cover in detail what transpired there.

The channels conveniently failed to acknowledge that the Aam Aadmis of India surviving in Mumbai were not affected by Taj, Oberoi and Trident closing down for a couple of weeks or months. What mattered to them was the
stoppage of BEST buses and suburban trains even for one hour. But the channels were not covering that aspect of the terror attack. Such information at best merited a scroll line, while the cameras have to be dedicated for real time thriller unfolding at Taj or Nariman Bhavan.

The so called justification for the hype the channels built around heritage site Taj falling down (CST is also a heritage site), is that Hotel Taj is where the rich and the powerful of India and the globe congregate. It is a
symbol or icon of power of money and politics, not India. It is the icon of the financiers and swindlers of India. The Mumbai and India were built by the Aam Aadmis who passed through CST and Taj was the oasis of peace and privacy for those who wielded power over these mass of labouring classes.
Leopold club and Taj were the haunts of rich spoilt kids who would drive their vehicles over sleeping Aam Aadmis on the pavement, the Mafiosi of
Mumbai forever financing the glitterati of Bollywood (and also the terrorists) , Political brokers and industrialists.

It is precisely because Taj is the icon of power and not people that the terrorists chose to strike.
The terrorists have understood after several efforts that the Aam Aadmi will never break down even if you bomb her markets and trains. He/she was resilient because that is the only way he/she can even survive.

Resilience was another word that annoyed the pundits of news channels and their patrons this time. What resilience, enough is enough, said Pranoy Roy's channel on the left side of the channel spectrum. Same sentiments were
echoed by Arnab Goswami representing the right wing of the broadcast media whose time is now. Can Rajdeep be far behind in this game of one-upmanship over TRPs ? They all attacked resilience this time. They wanted firm action
from the government in tackling terror.

The same channels celebrated resilience when bombs went off in trains and markets killing and maiming the Aam Aadmis. The resilience of the ordinary
worker suited the rich business class of Mumbai since work or manufacture or film shooting did not stop. When it came to them, the rich shamelessly exhibited their lack of nerves and refused to be resilient themselves. They
cry for government intervention now to protect their private spas and swimming pools and bars and restaurants, similar to the way in which Citibank, General Motors and the ilk cry for government money when their coffers are emptied by their own ideologies.

The terrorists have learnt that the ordinary Indian is unperturbed by terror. For one whose daily existence itself is a terror of government sponsored inflation and market sponsored exclusion, pain is something he has learnt to live with. The rich of Mumbai and India Inc are facing the pain for the first time and learning about it just as the middle classes of India
learnt about violation of human rights only during emergency, a cool 28 years after independence.

And human rights were another favourite issue for the channels to whip at times of terrorism.
Arnab Goswami in an animated voice wondered where were those champions of human rights now, not to be seen applauding the brave and selfless police officers who gave up their life in fighting terrorism.. Well, the counter
question would be where were you when such officers were violating the human rights of Aam Aadmis. Has there ever been any 24 hour non stop coverage of violence against dalits and adivasis of this country?

This definitely was not the time to manufacture consent for the extra legal and third degree methods of interrogation of police and army but Arnabs don't miss a single opportunity to serve their class masters, this time the
jingoistic patriotism came in handy to whitewash the entire uniformed services.

The sacrifice of the commandos or the police officers who went down dying at the hands of ruthless terrorists is no doubt heart rending but in vain in a
situation which needed not just bran but also brain. Israel has a point when it says the operations were misplanned resulting in the death of its nationals here.

Kakares and Salaskars would not be dead if they did not commit the mistake of travelling by the same vehicle. It is a basic lesson in management that the top brass should never travel together in crisis. The terrorists, if
only they had watched the channels, would have laughed their hearts out when the Chief of the Marine commandos, an elite force, masking his face so unprofessionally in a see-through cloth, told the media that the commandos had no idea about the structure of the Hotel Taj which they were trying to liberate. But the terrorists knew the place thoroughly, he acknowledged.

Is it so difficult to obtain a ground plan of Hotel Taj and discuss operation strategy thoroughly for at least one hour before entering? This is
something even an event manager would first ask for, if he had to fix 25 audio systems and 50 CCtvs for a cultural event in a hotel. Would not Ratan Tata have provided a plan of his ancestral hotel to the commandos within one
hour considering the mighty apparatus at his and government's disposal? Are satellite pictures only available for terrorists and not the government agencies? In an operation known to consume time, one more hour for preparation would have only improved the efficiency of execution.

Sacrifices become doubly tragic in unprofessional circumstances. But the Aam Aadmis always believe that terror-shooters do better planning than terrorists. And the gullible media in a jingoistic mood would not raise any question about any of these issues. They after all have their favourite whipping boy รข€" the politician the eternal entertainer for the non-voting
rich classes of India.

Arnabs and Rajdeeps would wax eloquent on Manmohan Singh and Advani visiting Mumbai separately and not together showing solidarity even at this hour of
national crisis. What a farce? Why can't these channels pool together all their camera crew and reporters at this time of national calamity and share the sound and visual bites which could mean a wider and deeper coverage of
events with such a huge
human resource to command? Why should Arnab and Rajdeep and Barkha keep harping every five minutes that this piece of information was exclusive to
their channel, at the time of such a national crisis? Is this the time to promote the channel? If that is valid, the politician promoting his own political constituency is equally valid. And the duty of the politician is
to do politics, his politics. It is for the people to evaluate that
politics.

And terrorism is not above politics. It is politics by other means. To come to grips with it and to eventually eliminate it, the practice of politics by
proper means needs constant fine tuning and improvement. Decrying all politics and politicians, only helps terrorists and dictators who are the two sides of the same coin. And the rich and powerful always prefer terrorists and dictators to do business with.

Those caught in this crossfire are always the Aam Aadmis whose deaths are not even mourned - the taxi driver who lost the entire family at CST firing, the numerous waiters and stewards who lost their lives working in Taj for a
monthly salary that would be one time bill for their masters

Ruchi Mann said...

@ finding thyself:

I couldn't agree more!!